Last night I got a call from my friend Martina, who told me that she had a school video project due the next day and she needed help. She edited this cool stop-motion video in Windows Movie Maker on her home computer, but since her computer was so old and slow, Movie Maker was constantly crashing and she was barely able to work on it at all. Somehow she managed to edit the movie and export it as two WMV9 clips (Movie Maker allows export to either WMV9 or DV, and the computer didn’t have enough space to export as DV or WMV was the default option and Martina didn’t know how to switch it — I’m not sure), but she still needed to join the two clips together and add a song as the audio track. She burned the two files and the song to a CD and brought them over to my friend Simon’s house, to put the finishing touches on the project in iMovie on Simon’s fancy new MacBook Pro.
Unfortunately, when she got there, she realized iMovie is unable to import WMV files. She and Simon found Flip4Mac, the Microsoft-recommended plugin which supposedly allows you to play WMV files through QuickTime. After installing this, they tried dragging Martina’s WMV files into iMovie, and it appeared that it was going to work. A progress bar popped up and it started to import the files into iMovie. Unfortunately, when it was finished, a giant message telling them to upgrade to Flip4Mac Pro appeared watermarked across the entire video. That’s when they called me. I cringed a little when I heard what they were trying to do, since I have tried to convert WMV files before on both Mac and Linux and knew that it is a pain. However, I like being known as the computer nerd that all my friends call when they need assistance, so I selflessly and heroically agreed to drive over and figure it out for them.
When I got there, I thought of a few things that could maybe work. I downloaded ffmpegX, a Mac OS X front-end to both the ffmpeg and mencoder conversion tools. I figured this might be able to convert WMV to MOV or some other format compatible with iMovie. While I still think ffmpeg and mencoder are great tools (ffmpegX not so much, it’s shareware that derives practically all its functionality from two free software programs — so basically they want you to pay for a snazzy interface… this is a typical problem I’ve run into on Macs), their ability to handle WMV files is flaky at best. This isn’t their fault though, WMV is a closed-source format that Microsoft controls. In other words, I couldn’t get ffmpegX to convert the files into a format that would work with iMovie.
Determined to figure this problem out, I did a little research online. I found avidemux, a free software program I had used on Linux. I hadn’t realized that ports existed for both Mac and Windows. Unfortunately (of course), avidemux for Mac requires X11.app, which Simon didn’t have installed. It took me forever to find it — maybe it’s just me, but it really seemed like Apple went out of its way to hide the download site for this program. I finally found it (somehow) and installed it, but didn’t have any luck with avidemux either. It was able to open the WMV files and append the second clip to the first, but I couldn’t get it to export to a usable format.
At this point, I had spent probably 2 hours (with a couple 10 minute breaks to play Super Mario All-Stars on Simon’s SNES) trying these techniques. I was so frustrated that I decided to try something so evil and diabolical I thought for sure it would work. I tried to download a cracked version of Flip4Mac Pro. I know, I know… this is illegal and I don’t AT ALL condone this sort of activity, but we were so desperate to finish Martina’s movie in time for her class the next day that we were willing to try anything. None of us had any money either, so we couldn’t have just bought it (although I don’t think I would have let Martina or Simon buy it even if they had the money — it’s such a rip-off). I searched a couple BitTorrent sites and found the Universal Binary version that we needed to be able to import WMV directly into iMovie. I started to download them, and waited. And waited. And waited. It wasn’t working. No one was seeding either of these torrent files, so they weren’t downloading. In retrospect, I’m glad it didn’t work. Now that I’ve switched over to Linux, the idea of using pirated software really bothers me. Why do something illegal when there are tons of free alternatives?
After this failed, I hopelessly looked at Martina and shook my head. I don’t think it’s going to work. She said, “Oh. Okay, that’s alright.” I could see the disappointment in her eyes. Completely discouraged and feeling that I had lost my reputation as the dork who could fix any computer problem among my friends, I started putting my shoes on, getting ready to leave. Then it dawned on me — aren’t there websites out there that allow you to edit your videos online??! I threw my shoes off and shouted, “Wait! I think I know how to do it!” I raced over to the computer and opened up a Firefox window. I quickly remembered three video-sharing sites off the top of my head that allowed you to edit your clips — Motionbox, Jumpcut, and Eyespot. I paused for a second, thinking, “Wait… you can edit your clips online, but would they let you download them?” I froze, thinking we might be out of luck. What are the chances that one of these sites is going to not only allow you to edit your videos, but download them too? I did a quick search of all three, and there it was — right on an Eyespot video page was a “Download” bar that had buttons to download the video in your choice of FIVE different formats (Mac, PC, iPod, PSP, and DivX)!
If only I had thought of this simple solution two hours before. The actually editing was incredibly easy — I uploaded the two WMV files and the song, went to the “Mixer” section, dragged the two clips onto the timeline and muted them, dragged the song onto the “Audio” bar, named my final edit, clicked “Mix and Play”, and tada! It started mixing the clips. It took only about 40 seconds. I then went to the video’s page and clicked the “Mac” download in the download section. A message popped up saying an email with the download link would be sent to me shortly. I check about a minute or two later and sure enough, there it was in my Inbox. I downloaded the MOV file, imported it into iDVD (in the end we didn’t even NEED to use iMovie!) and burned it onto a DVD. After it finished we all gathered around the TV, put the DVD and watched Martina’s cool short stop-motion film!
Needless to say, I felt that I owed it to Eyespot to tell this story. They really saved the day. As for the quality of the finished product, Martina was happy with it, and that was all that mattered. I’m not really sure if Eyespot adds any compression to the downloaded video file — it would’ve been hard to tell, since it had already been heavily compressed when it was converted from DV to WMV. I only watched the final product once on the TV, and I was mostly watching it for the film itself, not to check out the quality, but I don’t remember it being really pixelated or anything like that.
You know, after having the pleasure of editing a short film on Eyespot, it kind of inspired me to want to make my own videos. I know that Linux is a bit lacking in the simple video editing department (there’s Kino, but last time I tried using it, it crashed a few times and so I didn’t experiment with it much more), so something like Eyespot might be the perfect solution. There is a 100MB limit per video file, but that’s the same limit as YouTube so you can’t really complain (although YouTube also puts a 10 minute limit on the video files, and it doesn’t seem that Eyespot does that. So if you have a long video that you’re able to compress to under 100MB, Eyespot might be the better choice!). I didn’t even get a chance to experiment with the effects and transitions on Eyespot, because Martina’s video didn’t require them.
If you’ve got a video you’d like to edit, you might want to give Eyespot a try. Even if all you’d like to do is combine to clips like I did, it was a pretty easy solution, especially if you’ve got two files in a proprietary format that you’re unable to do anything with.
Recent Comments